Blue Heaven
4.6$$· ModerateOpen now · until 10:00 PMIconic Key West venue serving Caribbean dishes and key lime pie

Located in Key West's historic Bahama Village, Blue Heaven is a celebrated open-air restaurant known for its whimsical setting where roaming chickens and cats stroll amidst lush courtyard shade. The menu highlights a delicious blend of Floridian and Caribbean flavors, ranging from hearty breakfasts and Jamaican jerk dishes to fresh seafood. No visit is complete without trying their famous mile-high Key Lime Pie topped with a mountain of meringue.
History
Originally built as a house in the 1800s, Blue Heaven has transformed over the years into a beloved eatery. It has a rich history intertwined with the vibrant culture of Key West, attracting locals and tourists alike for decades.
Expert notes
- Arrive early to avoid long wait times, especially for brunch.
- Try to sit outside for a true Key West experience.
- Enjoy the live music during your visit.
- Explore the unique art and decor around the restaurant.
- Keep an eye out for the resident roosters!
- Pair your meal with a tropical drink.
- Check the menu for daily specials.
- Don't forget to try the homemade key lime pie.
- Take your time to relax and enjoy the atmosphere.
- Bring sunscreen if dining outside during the day.
Features
- Brunch menu
- Caribbean cuisine
- Free Wi-Fi
- Fresh seafood
- Friendly staff
- Full bar
- Garden seating
- Historic building
- Kid's menu
- Live music
- Outdoor seating
- Pet-friendly
- Takeout available
- Unique decor
- Vegetarian options
More places to eat in Key West
The Conch Shack$Iconic outdoor Duval Street counter serving fresh Key West seafood classics.
Mangoes Restaurant$$Lively outdoor Duval Street dining featuring fresh seafood and tropical drinks.
Banana Cafe$$Charming French bistro on Duval Street serving crêpes and classic fare
The Stoned Crab$$$Dockside seafood dining and organic cocktails along Key West's waterfront
Cuban Coffee Queen Downtown (Southard and Duval)$Authentic Cuban coffee, classic sandwiches, and relaxed shaded patio seating.
Sunset Grille & Raw Bar$$Oceanfront dining and raw bar seafood near the Seven Mile Bridge