Pepe's Cafe

Established in 1909, Pepe's Cafe is the oldest restaurant in Key West and a beloved local institution. Located on Caroline Street, this rustic joint serves hearty breakfasts, fresh oysters, steaks, and homemade Key lime pie. Guests can dine indoors among walls lined with local history or relax on the breezy outdoor patio.

History

Founded in 1909, Pepe's Cafe is one of the oldest restaurants in Key West. It has a rich history that reflects the island's colorful past, serving both locals and tourists for over a century. The café has maintained its original charm while adapting to modern tastes and trends.

Expert notes

• Arrive early for breakfast to avoid long wait times.
• Try to sit outside for a more authentic Key West experience.
• Check the daily specials for fresh, seasonal dishes.
• Ask your server for recommendations on local favorites.
• Pair your meal with a refreshing tropical drink.
• Don't forget to try the key lime pie for dessert.
• Take your time to enjoy the atmosphere and local art.
• Consider visiting during off-peak hours for a quieter experience.
• Bring sunscreen if you're dining outside during the day.
• Check for live music events to enhance your dining experience.

Features

• air conditioning
• breakfast served all day
• free Wi-Fi
• friendly staff
• full bar
• live music
• local art
• outdoor seating
• pet-friendly
• seafood dishes
• seasonal specials
• takeout available
• tropical cocktails
• vegetarian options
• vintage decor