Keuka Restaurant
4.3$$· ModerateOpen now · until 10:00 PMRelaxed Penn Yan eatery offering generous steaks, seafood, and local drinks.

Located on East Main Street in Penn Yan, Keuka Restaurant is a welcoming local spot offering a wide-ranging menu of steaks, seafood, pasta, and pub favorites. The warm, wood-accented space provides a comfortable backdrop for lunch or dinner while exploring the Finger Lakes region. Guests can enjoy generous portions alongside a strong selection of beer, wine, and cocktails.
Expert notes
- Check the menu online before visiting.
- Consider trying the daily specials.
- Ask the staff for wine pairings with your meal.
- Arrive early to enjoy a drink at the bar.
- Inquire about group dining options.
- Be sure to save room for dessert!
- Check for seasonal hours during holidays.
- Follow them on social media for updates and promotions.
- Bring a jacket for outdoor seating in the evenings.
- Use the restroom before peak dining hours to avoid lines.
Features
- Catering Services
- Cozy Atmosphere
- Full Bar
- Kid-Friendly Options
- Live Music Events
- Loyalty Program
- Outdoor Seating
- Parking Available
- Private Dining
- Seasonal Menu
- Special Event Hosting
- Takeout Available
- Wheelchair Accessible
- Wi-Fi
- Wine Tastings
Special occasion reservations
- Reservations can be made online through the website.
- You can also call the restaurant directly to reserve a table.
- It's recommended to book at least a week in advance for special occasions.
More places to eat in Finger Lakes
The Shack$Savor delicious smoked barbecue and fresh donuts near Keuka Lake.
The Creamery$Explore local history at Skaneateles' historic creamery turned town museum
The Park Inn$$Polished boutique inn and restaurant in historic downtown Hammondsport
Main Deck$Upscale lakefront dining on Keuka Lake with fresh local flavors
Naples Wood Fired Pizza & Smokehouse BBQ$$Wood fired pizzas and slow smoked barbecue in the Finger Lakes
The Red Barn$$Enjoy rustic charm and serene countryside views in the Finger Lakes.