The Wagner Restaurant

4.6$· InexpensiveOpen now · until 2:00 PM

Classic local diner in Penn Yan serving hearty American breakfast favorites.

The Wagner Restaurant
Website Directions 315-536-8062

Located in downtown Penn Yan near Keuka Lake, The Wagner Restaurant is a beloved, casual spot popular with locals and visitors alike. It specializes in classic American diner fare, serving up hearty breakfasts, homemade comfort dishes, burgers, and Friday fish fries. With its unpretentious atmosphere and welcoming service, it offers an authentic local dining experience in the Finger Lakes region.

Quick tip: Arrive early on weekend mornings to avoid a wait, or visit on Friday evening for their local favorite fish fry.

Expert notes

  • Make a reservation during peak seasons to ensure a table.
  • Check their website for daily specials and events.
  • Explore the local farmers' market before dining for fresh produce.
  • Ask the staff about the origin of the ingredients.
  • Pair your meal with a local wine selection for a complete experience.

Features

  • Artisan desserts
  • Cooking classes
  • Cozy dining atmosphere
  • Event hosting
  • Family-friendly environment
  • Farm tours
  • Friendly staff
  • Live music events
  • Locally sourced ingredients
  • Outdoor seating
  • Seasonal menu
  • Special dietary options
  • Sustainable practices
  • Takeout options
  • Wine selection

Special occasion reservations

Reservations can be made through their website or by phone.

More places to eat in Finger Lakes

All places to eat in Finger Lakes →