New York Pasta Garden
4.4$$· ModerateOpen now · until 3:00 PMRelaxed Italian dining and classic pasta dishes in Key West

Tucked into Duval Square, New York Pasta Garden serves classic Italian comfort food in a vibrant garden atmosphere. The menu features heart-warming dishes like lasagna, chicken marsala, and garlic knots, along with a full wine list and happy hour options. It is a cozy, casual destination ideal for a relaxed lunch or dinner on Duval Street.
Expert notes
- Make a reservation during peak season for the best experience.
- Arrive early to enjoy a pre-dinner drink on the patio.
- Ask your server for recommendations on wine pairings.
- Try to save room for dessert, especially the tiramisu!
- Check their social media for daily specials and events.
Features
- Cozy Atmosphere
- Daily Specials
- Family-Friendly
- Friendly Staff
- Gluten-Free Options
- Homemade Pasta
- Outdoor Seating
- Takeout Available
- Vegetarian Options
- Wine Selection
Special occasion reservations
Reservations can be made online through their website or by calling the restaurant.
More places to eat in Key West
Key West Taco Dog Food Stand$Casual late-night food cart serving signature taco hot dogs on Duval Street
Mangoes Restaurant$$Lively outdoor Duval Street dining featuring fresh seafood and tropical drinks.
Key West Fine Wines$Upscale Key West wine shop offering boutique vintages and gourmet provisions
B.O.'s Fish Wagon$$Rustic Key West driftwood shack serving fresh grouper and conch fritters
Smoked BBQ$$Savor tender slow-smoked brisket and ribs with scenic marina views.
Sushi Song - Key West$$Chic Duval Street sushi lounge serving fresh rolls and craft cocktails