New York Pasta Garden
4.4$$· ModerateRelaxed Italian dining and classic pasta dishes in Key West
Tucked into Duval Square, New York Pasta Garden serves classic Italian comfort food in a vibrant garden atmosphere. The menu features heart-warming dishes like lasagna, chicken marsala, and garlic knots, along with a full wine list and happy hour options. It is a cozy, casual destination ideal for a relaxed lunch or dinner on Duval Street.
Expert notes
- Make a reservation during peak season for the best experience.
- Arrive early to enjoy a pre-dinner drink on the patio.
- Ask your server for recommendations on wine pairings.
- Try to save room for dessert, especially the tiramisu!
- Check their social media for daily specials and events.
Features
- Cozy Atmosphere
- Daily Specials
- Family-Friendly
- Friendly Staff
- Gluten-Free Options
- Homemade Pasta
- Outdoor Seating
- Takeout Available
- Vegetarian Options
- Wine Selection
Special occasion reservations
Reservations can be made online through their website or by calling the restaurant.
More places to eat in Key West
Dante's Key West Pool Bar & Restaurant$$Lively Key West pool bar serving fresh seafood, tropical cocktails, and music
Old Town Bakery$$Charming Key West bakery serving fresh artisan breads and sweet treats
Hogfish Bar & Grill$$Relaxed waterfront seafood dining with famous local hogfish sandwiches
Banana Cafe$$Charming French bistro on Duval Street serving crêpes and classic fare
Duffy's Steak & Lobster House$$Classic surf and turf dining in a cozy Key West setting
Southern Most Deli$Classic Cuban sandwiches, coffee, and daily grocery staples in Key West