The Old Mill Creamery
4.4$· InexpensiveHandcrafted ice cream and sweet treats in historic Pigeon Forge

Located in Old Mill Square in Pigeon Forge, The Old Mill Creamery serves churned ice cream, classic parlor favorites, cookies, and signature sundaes. Visitors can choose from a wide selection of signature and traditional flavors before heading outdoors. The shop features comfortable outdoor seating in a charming historic atmosphere near the Great Smoky Mountains.
Expert notes
- Try the seasonal flavors for a unique experience.
- Ask about their specialty sundaes for a treat.
- Enjoy your ice cream outside for a lovely view.
- Take your time to choose from their extensive menu.
- Don't forget to sample before you decide on a flavor.
- Check for any special events during your visit.
- Consider visiting during off-peak hours for a quieter experience.
- Pair your ice cream with a slice of pie from the Old Mill.
- Take pictures of the beautiful scenery around the creamery.
- Grab a souvenir cup for a memorable treat.
- Enjoy the ambiance of the historic Old Mill nearby.
- Ask staff for recommendations on popular flavors.
- Try their ice cream in a freshly made waffle cone.
- Visit in the evening for a charming atmosphere.
- Bring friends or family to share the experience.
More places to eat in Great Smoky Mountains
Johnny Carino's$$Relaxed Italian dining serving classic pasta dishes in central Pigeon Forge
Shoney's$Classic family diner serving American comfort food in the Smokies.
The Donut Friar$Iconic Gatlinburg bakery serving fresh warm donuts and coffee daily
The Wild Plum Tea Room$$Cozy mountain teahouse serving specialty teas and lunches in Gatlinburg
Bennett's Pit Bar-B-Que$$Hearty hickory-smoked meats and classic Southern sides in Great Smoky Mountains
Pigeon Forge Deli$Discover oversized hot subs and homemade pretzels at this hidden gem